"Come on, kid... Don't make me do this. You're not gonna win." — Sean and Nicholas in "Faith"
As Lisbeth's right-hand man, Nicholas acts as an enforcer and likes to use violence over words. He can be best described as "inclined to pride" according to Lisbeth and is easily prone to have a violent temper, as he is not afraid to injure or threaten anybody who he deems as problematic, even going as far to threaten Sean at gunpoint. However, he is hesitant when it comes to killing anybody despite his violent demeanor. He is noted to remain in contact with white gangs, indicating that he held supremacist views in the past which he may still hold today.
Despite having never read the Bible, ironically, he is said to have a strong faith in Christianity.
He is also proven to be homophobic, as he calls Jacob a slur should he catch the latter in Lisbeth's office.
Nicholas is a tall, muscular man with black, neatly-combed hair and a strong jawline. He wears a white button-up shirt with rolled-up sleeves, brown slacks, and brown dress shoes.
In 1997, Nicholas was incarcerated in Salt Lake City for 11 years until his release in 2008 for reasons unknown. He formed connections with white gangs whom he still remains in contact with in the present. A newspaper clipping incuded alongside his file indicates that, as a teenager, he and two other teens drunkenly robbed, beat, and murdered a liquor store owner in South Salt Lake. He is a former meth addict, a topic which he dislikes speaking about.
Episode Four - "Faith"
As Sean Diaz watches Lisbeth's church service, Nicholas brings Daniel Diaz out onto the stage and watches in awe as he uses his powers to raise the cross above the audience. After Lisbeth takes Daniel away, Nicholas steps up to the podium and reminds the audience to donate to the church and participate in next Sunday's picnic raffle before telling them to save any questions for him outside.
Later, after Sean is brought down by Sarah Lee Hackerman to reunite with his brother, Nicholas takes Sean's backpack and forces him out of the church at Lisbeth's request. Outside, Nicholas tells Sean to leave and flashes his gun; if Sean tries to get up, Nicholas punches him back down before closing the gates and heading back inside.
As Jacob and Sean infiltrate Lisbeth's house, Karen Reynolds calls Sean and warns him that Nicholas is approaching the house; if they had raised the suspicion of Helen Miller or Derek earlier, she tells them that he spoke with them, while if they didn't, she tells him that he's holding some files and doesn't seem suspicious.
If Sean rejects Karen's plan, doesn't hide, or fails to clean up their evidence of being there while having not alerted anyone, Nicholas finds him and punches him and Jacob before dragging Sean to the church. If Sean accepted Karen's plan and hides, Nicholas leaves the room after hearing shouts outside due to the burning building. If Sean didn't accept Karen's plan, cleaned up the evidence, and hid, Nicholas searches through some files before leaving, unaware of the boys' presence.
If Sean was caught, Nicholas drags Sean into the church and tosses him to the ground, informing Lisbeth that he'd caught him and Jacob in her office; if he wasn't, Nicholas enters the church after Daniel throws Sean to the ground with his powers. As Sean tries to get through to Daniel, Nicholas begins beating him up before eventually pulling out his gun at Lisbeth's request; as he hesitates to shoot him, Daniel tosses him to the ground of the burning church with his powers. If Lisbeth is killed at the door, Nicholas stumbles out of the church alone; if she wasn't, Nicholas drags her out of the church as she struggles to go back to it before they both fall to their knees.
- Lisbeth Fischer - Nicholas is very loyal to Lisbeth and willing to do anything for her, such as resort to violence towards apparent intruders and rush to her aid after hearing a noise from within the church. Within Lisbeth's file on him, a note can be found addressed to an Elizabeth thanking her for helping him out of a "downward spiral [he'd] been falling in for weeks" and finding a motel room for him to stay at. Before the letter is cut off, he mentions that he remembers that she was looking for hands to help her build something, which was presumably Haven Point.
- Jacob Hackerman - Nicholas dislikes Jacob and disapproves of his homosexuality, being able to call him a slur and tell him that he was "always trouble". If he catches the two and leads Sean to the church, Nicholas tells Lisbeth that he "took care of that Judas" in reference to Jacob.